There are some situations where it makes sense to breastfeed from only one breast. Weaning from one breast sounds kind of funny, but it actually can work! This happens more often with moms who are nursing their babies than it does with exclusive pumpers, as the baby might not like nursing from one side – it might get too full (making it hard for the baby to latch), it might not produce enough (frustrating the baby), etc.
This post may contain affiliate links, which means that if you click through and make a purchase, I’ll be compensated at no additional cost to you. I only recommend products I love! More info here.
In some cases, though, it can also make sense for exclusive pumpers to pump from only one side. The main reason for this is recurrent breast issues, such as clogged ducts, thrush, mastitis, and general breast pain that is mostly limited to one side.
Mo from Life and Love in the Petri Dish was an exclusive pumper for her beautiful daughter and got mastitis five times in three months, all on one side. She was able to wean from that side and continue to pump for her daughter on the other. She was nice enough to answer a few questions for me about how she did it and what she’d recommend for anyone trying the same thing. Here they are:
On your blog, you mentioned that you gradually pumped for a few minutes less from the left side. Was there anything more to the physical process of weaning from that side? How long did it take?
I cut down pumping by a minute or two each day, per pumping session. That sort of signaled my body to slow the milk production. It took about a week, if I remember, and I took it really slowly because weaning can CAUSE mastitis, and that was why I was weaning in the first place. The weaning was “facilitated” after coming on the heels of so many mastitis infections – during each one my supply dropped, so it was already much lower on that one side.
Honestly, in my recollection, it was more difficult emotionally than physically (probably much of that hormonally driven). I’d really, really wanted to breastfeed my daughter, and when I couldn’t get her to latch, really wanted to provide her milk. I knew that I would lose a lot of supply by weaning on one side (which I did), and that was tough.
Did you have any problems with leaking on the left when you were still pumping from the right side? Did you feel lopsided?
I had a bit of leakage – I’d just attach a pump bottle on both sides and allow the “unpumped” side to collect. It wasn’t much, and I can’t remember how long it lasted for.
YES I felt lopsided, and I looked really lopsided – one huge breast and nipple and one small one. My husband said I looked like a martian. (Thanks, Will!)
You mentioned on your blog that it was difficult for you emotionally to wean from one side because it made much harder to exclusively feed Magpie breast milk. Looking back now, are you glad that you did it?
I really had to do it. I could not go on getting sick that often (102+ degree fever each time, etc), so i haven’t really looked back nostalgically. It was what it was. I do really wish she’d been able to breastfeed directly, but we have a very close relationship and I tried as hard as I could with that. I have to let it go.
What would you tell someone who was planning to wean from one breast? Any tips or warnings?
My tips would be to go slowly. Know that physically it’ll look weird but things all go back to normal once you wean entirely. (Although I weaned in late October and I still have milk in my other breast – much longer than I expected).
You can read more about Mo’s experience as an exclusive pumper here. Thanks to Mo for sharing her experience! And if you have experience weaning from one breast, let us know how it went for you!